Título:
Control de manganeso en el tratamiento del agua potable : análisis de oxidantes químicos y propuesta de interoxidación con permanganato de potasio : Usina Laguna del Cisne.
Otros títulos:
Coordinador:
Director:
Compilador:
Autor:
Indarte Bonifacino, Enrique
Tutor:
González, Alice Elizabeth
Tipo de documento:
Tesis de maestría
Editor:
Palabras clave:
Manganeso
Tratamiento de agua potable
Oxidación
Permanganato de potasio
Dióxido de cloro
Interoxidación
Cinética de oxidación
Punto de aplicación del oxidante
Manganese
Drinking water treatment
Oxidation
Potassium permanganate
Chlorine dioxide
Intermediate oxidation
Oxidation kinetics
Oxidant application point
Tratamiento de agua potable
Oxidación
Permanganato de potasio
Dióxido de cloro
Interoxidación
Cinética de oxidación
Punto de aplicación del oxidante
Manganese
Drinking water treatment
Oxidation
Potassium permanganate
Chlorine dioxide
Intermediate oxidation
Oxidation kinetics
Oxidant application point
Descriptores:
Año de publicación:
2026
Contenido:
Resumen:
El manganeso constituye un desafío para el tratamiento convencional del agua potable debido a las dificultades para promover su oxidación, precipitación y remoción dentro de los tiempos disponibles en planta. Su presencia puede favorecer la formación de depósitos en las redes de distribución y generar problemas de turbiedad, coloración y rechazo por parte de los usuarios, mientras que la evolución de las recomendaciones internacionales tiende hacia concentraciones cada vez menores en el agua tratada. La presente investigación analiza la utilización de oxidantes químicos para el control del manganeso, profundizando en el comportamiento del dióxido de cloro (ClO₂) y el permanganato de potasio (KMnO₄), sus mecanismos de acción, interacciones y condiciones de aplicación. Particularmente, se estudia la viabilidad de una estrategia de interoxidación mediante KMnO₄ aplicada sobre el agua clarificada inmediatamente antes de la filtración, como alternativa a la intercloración convencional. La metodología integra análisis termodinámico, cinético, experimental y operacional. Se desarrollaron diagramas de Pourbaix específicos mediante la ecuación de Nernst y se evaluó la influencia de la temperatura, concentración de manganeso y carbono inorgánico. Complementariamente, se analizaron las cinéticas de oxidación, las interacciones entre oxidantes y con carbón activado en polvo, los riesgos de sobredosificación y las condiciones de control mediante pH, potencial redox (Eh), manganeso y permanganato residual. La estrategia propuesta fue implementada y evaluada en la Usina Laguna del Cisne (Canelones, Uruguay), incorporando además un análisis estadístico de series operacionales de manganeso, turbiedad y reclamos. Los resultados muestran que los diagramas de Pourbaix constituyen una herramienta adecuada para interpretar las transformaciones del manganeso, aunque requieren complementarse con consideraciones cinéticas para evaluar su ocurrencia dentro de los tiempos disponibles en planta. Tanto el ClO₂ como el KMnO₄ presentan condiciones termodinámicamente favorables para la oxidación del manganeso y pueden alcanzar cinéticas compatibles con los tiempos disponibles en planta bajo condiciones adecuadas de pH, temperatura y dosificación, aunque difieren en sus condiciones de aplicación, interacciones, productos secundarios y requerimientos operacionales. El análisis desarrollado destaca además al punto de dosificación como una variable estratégica: la aplicación de KMnO₄ sobre agua clarificada reduce la influencia de demandas competitivas presentes en el agua bruta y permite aprovechar la filtración como barrera inmediata para la retención del MnO₂ formado. La evaluación operacional correspondiente a agosto de 2025–julio de 2026 mostró un cambio de comportamiento posterior a la implementación. La turbiedad media del agua elevada disminuyó de 0,301 a 0,177 NTU (−41,2 %), con diferencias estadísticamente significativas entre los períodos pre y post (p < 0,001) y una reducción significativa de la variabilidad. Para el manganeso, las concentraciones en agua elevada fueron menores en el período Post al restringir el análisis a rangos definidos de Mn en agua bruta (−20,7 a −24,4 %; Mann–Whitney, p < 0,05), aunque persistieron diferencias en la carga de entrada entre períodos, impidiendo aislar completamente el efecto de la modificación operacional. Asimismo, la asociación entre manganeso y turbiedad, ambos determinados en agua elevada, observada antes del cambio dejó de resultar significativa en el período posterior. Por otra parte, se observó una asociación temporal positiva entre la turbiedad del agua elevada y los reclamos de calidad, considerada como evidencia complementaria y no causal. Estos resultados son consistentes con una modificación favorable del comportamiento operacional del agua elevada posterior a la implementación, aunque el carácter observacional del análisis no permite atribuir exclusivamente al cambio operacional la totalidad de las variaciones observadas. Como resultado, se propone una estrategia integrada de interoxidación con KMnO₄ acompañada por un esquema de control operacional basado en el seguimiento conjunto de pH, Eh, manganeso, permanganato residual, turbiedad y cloro residual. La implementación mostró una factibilidad técnica y operacional favorable para el caso de estudio. La evaluación preliminar de trihalometanos (THM) mediante dos campañas posteriores a la implementación mostró bajos índices de THM con la nueva configuración; en agosto de 2026 se determinó directamente un índice de THM de 0,2 en el agua producida por Laguna del Cisne, luego de la cloración final y antes de su mezcla con el aporte metropolitano. En conjunto, el trabajo aporta una metodología integrada para el análisis, implementación y control de estrategias de oxidación química orientadas a mejorar la remoción de manganeso en plantas potabilizadoras convencionales.
Manganese poses a challenge to conventional drinking water treatment because of the difficulty of promoting its oxidation, precipitation, and removal within the contact times available at treatment plants. Its presence can contribute to deposit formation in distribution systems and cause turbidity, discoloration, and consumer rejection, while international recommendations are evolving toward increasingly lower concentrations in treated water. This research examines the use of chemical oxidants for manganese control, with particular emphasis on the behavior of chlorine dioxide (ClO₂) and potassium permanganate (KMnO₄), including their mechanisms of action, interactions, and application conditions. In particular, the feasibility of an intermediate oxidation strategy using KMnO₄ applied to clarified water immediately upstream of filtration is evaluated as an alternative to conventional intermediate chlorination. The methodology integrates thermodynamic, kinetic, experimental, and operational analyses. Specific Pourbaix diagrams were developed using the Nernst equation, and the effects of temperature, manganese concentration, and inorganic carbon were evaluated. In addition, oxidation kinetics, interactions between oxidants and with powdered activated carbon, overdosing risks, and operational control conditions based on pH, redox potential (Eh), manganese, and residual permanganate were assessed. The proposed strategy was implemented and evaluated at the Laguna del Cisne Water Treatment Plant (Canelones, Uruguay), together with a statistical analysis of operational time series for manganese, turbidity, and water-quality complaints. The results show that Pourbaix diagrams are useful tools for interpreting manganese transformations, although they must be complemented by kinetic considerations to assess whether such transformations can occur within the contact times available at the treatment plant. Both ClO₂ and KMnO₄ provide thermodynamically favorable conditions for manganese oxidation and can achieve kinetics compatible with the available plant contact times under suitable pH, temperature, and dosing conditions, although they differ in application requirements, interactions, secondary products, and operational considerations. The analysis also identifies the dosing point as a strategic variable: applying KMnO₄ to clarified water reduces the influence of competing oxidant demands present in raw water and allows filtration to act as an immediate barrier for retaining the MnO₂ formed. The operational evaluation covering August 2025 to July 2026 showed a change in system behavior following implementation. Mean turbidity in the pumped water decreased from 0.301 to 0.177 NTU (-41.2%), with statistically significant differences between the Pre and Post periods (p < 0.001) and a significant reduction in variability. For manganese, concentrations in pumped water were lower during the Post period when the analysis was restricted to defined raw-water manganese ranges (-20.7% to -24.4%; Mann–Whitney, p < 0.05). However, raw-water manganese concentrations also remained lower during the Post period within these subsets, preventing the independent effect of the operational modification from being fully isolated. In addition, the association between manganese and turbidity, both measured in pumped water, that was observed before the operational change was no longer statistically significant during the Post period. A positive temporal association was also observed between pumped-water turbidity and water-quality complaints; this was considered complementary rather than causal evidence. These findings are consistent with a favorable change in the operational behavior of the pumped water following implementation, although the observational nature of the analysis does not allow all observed changes to be attributed exclusively to the operational modification. As a result, an integrated intermediate oxidation strategy using KMnO₄ is proposed, together with an operational control scheme based on the combined monitoring of pH, Eh, manganese, residual permanganate, turbidity, and residual chlorine. Implementation showed favorable technical and operational feasibility for the case study. A preliminary assessment of trihalomethanes (THMs), based on two monitoring campaigns conducted after implementation, showed low THM indices under the new treatment configuration. In August 2026, a THM index of 0.2 was directly measured in water produced at the Laguna del Cisne Water Treatment Plant after final chlorination and before blending with water supplied from the metropolitan system. Overall, this study provides an integrated methodology for the analysis, implementation, and control of chemical oxidation strategies aimed at improving manganese removal in conventional drinking water treatment plants.
Manganese poses a challenge to conventional drinking water treatment because of the difficulty of promoting its oxidation, precipitation, and removal within the contact times available at treatment plants. Its presence can contribute to deposit formation in distribution systems and cause turbidity, discoloration, and consumer rejection, while international recommendations are evolving toward increasingly lower concentrations in treated water. This research examines the use of chemical oxidants for manganese control, with particular emphasis on the behavior of chlorine dioxide (ClO₂) and potassium permanganate (KMnO₄), including their mechanisms of action, interactions, and application conditions. In particular, the feasibility of an intermediate oxidation strategy using KMnO₄ applied to clarified water immediately upstream of filtration is evaluated as an alternative to conventional intermediate chlorination. The methodology integrates thermodynamic, kinetic, experimental, and operational analyses. Specific Pourbaix diagrams were developed using the Nernst equation, and the effects of temperature, manganese concentration, and inorganic carbon were evaluated. In addition, oxidation kinetics, interactions between oxidants and with powdered activated carbon, overdosing risks, and operational control conditions based on pH, redox potential (Eh), manganese, and residual permanganate were assessed. The proposed strategy was implemented and evaluated at the Laguna del Cisne Water Treatment Plant (Canelones, Uruguay), together with a statistical analysis of operational time series for manganese, turbidity, and water-quality complaints. The results show that Pourbaix diagrams are useful tools for interpreting manganese transformations, although they must be complemented by kinetic considerations to assess whether such transformations can occur within the contact times available at the treatment plant. Both ClO₂ and KMnO₄ provide thermodynamically favorable conditions for manganese oxidation and can achieve kinetics compatible with the available plant contact times under suitable pH, temperature, and dosing conditions, although they differ in application requirements, interactions, secondary products, and operational considerations. The analysis also identifies the dosing point as a strategic variable: applying KMnO₄ to clarified water reduces the influence of competing oxidant demands present in raw water and allows filtration to act as an immediate barrier for retaining the MnO₂ formed. The operational evaluation covering August 2025 to July 2026 showed a change in system behavior following implementation. Mean turbidity in the pumped water decreased from 0.301 to 0.177 NTU (-41.2%), with statistically significant differences between the Pre and Post periods (p < 0.001) and a significant reduction in variability. For manganese, concentrations in pumped water were lower during the Post period when the analysis was restricted to defined raw-water manganese ranges (-20.7% to -24.4%; Mann–Whitney, p < 0.05). However, raw-water manganese concentrations also remained lower during the Post period within these subsets, preventing the independent effect of the operational modification from being fully isolated. In addition, the association between manganese and turbidity, both measured in pumped water, that was observed before the operational change was no longer statistically significant during the Post period. A positive temporal association was also observed between pumped-water turbidity and water-quality complaints; this was considered complementary rather than causal evidence. These findings are consistent with a favorable change in the operational behavior of the pumped water following implementation, although the observational nature of the analysis does not allow all observed changes to be attributed exclusively to the operational modification. As a result, an integrated intermediate oxidation strategy using KMnO₄ is proposed, together with an operational control scheme based on the combined monitoring of pH, Eh, manganese, residual permanganate, turbidity, and residual chlorine. Implementation showed favorable technical and operational feasibility for the case study. A preliminary assessment of trihalomethanes (THMs), based on two monitoring campaigns conducted after implementation, showed low THM indices under the new treatment configuration. In August 2026, a THM index of 0.2 was directly measured in water produced at the Laguna del Cisne Water Treatment Plant after final chlorination and before blending with water supplied from the metropolitan system. Overall, this study provides an integrated methodology for the analysis, implementation, and control of chemical oxidation strategies aimed at improving manganese removal in conventional drinking water treatment plants.
Descripción:
Editorial:
Udelar.FI.
EN:
Financiadores:
Citación:
Indarte Bonifacino, E. Control de manganeso en el tratamiento del agua potable : análisis de oxidantes químicos y propuesta de interoxidación con permanganato de potasio : Usina Laguna del Cisne [en línea]. Tesis de maestría. Montevideo : Udelar. FI. IMFIA, 2026.
Citación:
metadata.cc.license.name:
Documento del Gobiberno:
ISBN:
e-ISBN:
ISSN:
1688-2792
ISMN:
Otros identificadores:
Título Obtenido:
Magíster en Ingeniería Ambiental
Facultad o Servicio que otorga el Título:
Universidad de la República (Uruguay). Facultad de Ingeniería
Licencia:
Atribución/Reconocimiento-NoComercial-SinDerivados 4.0 Internacional
Cobertura geográfica:
Laguna del Cisne, Departamento de Canelones, Uruguay.
Cobertura temporal:
metadata.dc.relation.IsVersionOf:
Clasificación:
Es versión de:
Colecciones:
| Ficheros | Descripción | Tamaño | Formato | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ind26.pdf | Tesis de Maestría | 8.52 MB | Adobe PDF |
Licencia Creative Commons:
Excepto donde se indique lo contrario, la licencia de este ítem se describe como Atribución/Reconocimiento-NoComercial-SinDerivados 4.0 Internacional

